The third and last protagonist of the e-book is Gretchen’s sister, Jane, who has to date adopted a reasonably standard life path. She’s married her faculty boyfriend, had two youngsters with him, and moved from Oak Park — the various and progressive neighborhood the place she grew up — to Lake Forest, described by Shut as a wealthy and homogeneous small metropolis north of Chicago, a spot the place Jane’s neighbors play gender-segregated bunco and assume that everybody else voted for Trump, too.
However Jane didn’t vote for Trump — in actual fact, she’s so appalled by him that she joins a “huddle” devoted to progressive causes again in Oak Park. “When Jane first heard the phrase,” Shut writes, “she imagined a bunch of girls, heads collectively, making quiet plans to avoid wasting the world. This, she realized, was pretty correct.”
The ideological conflict between Jane and her neighbors causes her to advocate for a transfer again to Oak Park, however her husband, Mike, is opposed. Actually, Mike is against lots of Jane’s concepts currently — and appears distracted by one thing Jane fears goes past politics.
This dance between the non-public and the political, and the way in which the latter impacts the previous, is essentially the most attention-grabbing thematic aspect of “Marrying the Ketchups.” Issues round them have fallen aside; the Sullivans are attempting to carry the middle, however more and more, they’re discovering that they will’t. The middle, on this case, is the restaurant itself — Sullivan’s — the destiny of which hangs perennially within the steadiness, and serves as a type of metonymous illustration of the late Bud Sullivan himself. No one desires to let go of it — as a result of what would they do subsequent? One different factor value noting about “Marrying the Ketchups” is the trick Shut has of taking what would possibly in any other case be an unusual alternate between unusual members of the family and one way or the other making it riveting. Half of this expertise stems from her merry humorousness — I smiled all through at numerous humorous observations that additionally rang true — and the opposite half stems from the knack she has of inventing story traces which have the texture of extraordinarily good gossip informed throughout a hightop desk over a beer with an outdated buddy. All the time, I needed to remain for an additional, simply to listen to extra.
One thing I’ve been fascinated with currently, as each a author and a instructor of writing, is how troublesome it’s to make on a regular basis occasions really feel fascinating in fiction. “Marrying the Ketchups” is an effective instance of a e-book that performs this magic trick. Lately, I’ve come to the conclusion that propulsiveness is a top quality that’s arduous to elucidate and tougher nonetheless to show — but when Jennifer Shut ever felt like operating a course on it, I’d join.
Liz Moore’s most up-to-date novel is “Lengthy Brilliant River.”
MARRYING THE KETCHUPS
By Jennifer Shut
320 pp. Alfred A. Knopf. $28.
